HOME | DD

Turmoil... — Description

In the Turboverse, this is a pivotal story segment occurring during the events of Turboverse RWBY Volume 3. This chapter focuses on humanizing Cinder Fall by exploring the deep psychological and physical scars of her past while the heroes (Team RWBY and JNPR) are on a long field trip to the City of Atlas.
The Narrative Setting
While other Beacon Academy students are enjoying their time off or hanging out, Cinder is depicted as an isolated figure. She watches them from afar, a reminder of the childhood she never had. This sets the stage for a confrontation where Team RWBY, Emerald Sustrai, and a disguised Neopolitan question Cinder's cold and distant behavior.
The Revelation of the Shock Collar
The most significant detail is the discovery of a permanent burn mark around Cinder's neck.
Blake's Theory: Blake Belladonna initially suspects the mark is a sign that Cinder is a Faunus hiding her identity, much like Blake once did.
The Reality: Cinder dismisses the theory and reveals the truth: during her time at the Glass Unicorn hotel, her adoptive mother (the Madame) forced her to wear a shock collar disguised as an ordinary necklace to keep her submissive.
The Scar: The marking is a permanent burn from years of physical abuse and electrocution, which eventually led to Cinder’s deep-seated hatred for those in power.
Origin Story Highlights
Cinder provides a detailed account of her upbringing that differs from her ruthless villain persona:
Mistral Orphanage: Her early years were spent in a Mistral orphanage, where she was overworked, underfed, and bullied by other children.
Awakening of Power: Cinder explains that her Semblance manifested not out of desire for strength, but out of pure hatred and anger as a response to the constant mistreatment.
The Mentor (Rhodes): She mentions being trained by a Huntsman named Rhodes. While she kept the full details vague to avoid suspicion, she admits that Rhodes taught her the skills of a Huntress so she could one day escape her "Step-Family."
Emotional Impact and Bonds
This revelation creates an unexpected bridge between the heroes and the villains:
Shared Sympathy: Weiss Schnee and Blake sympathized deeply with Cinder due to their own struggles with oppressive family dynamics and discrimination.
Innocence vs. Hatred: I want to emphasize that this version of Cinder is meant to show her innocent side, the person she could have been if she hadn't been overtaken by hatred.
Ruby and Cinder: In a particularly sweet moment, Cinder tells Ruby Rose that Ruby looks just like her, only with shorter hair, hinting at a potential sisterly or maternal bond that was never allowed to form.
Cinder's Inner Regret
A key takeaway from Turmoil is that Cinder is not entirely without conscience. Deep down, she harbors regret for killing her mentor, Rhodes, implying that her path to villainy was a result of tragic circumstances rather than pure malice.
Does Cinder tell the Truth of what really happened to Rhodes?
In the Turboverse AU, specifically within the Turmoil story segment, Cinder Fall does not tell the full truth about what happened to Rhodes.
The Controlled Truth
While Cinder opens up significantly to Team RWBY, Emerald, and Neo during their Atlas field trip, she is very calculated about the details regarding her former mentor:
Vague Mentions: She mentions that a Huntsman (Rhodes) trained her in secret so she could eventually run away and escape the abuse of her step-family.
Withholding the Climax: She deliberately keeps the full details vague to avoid raising suspicion about her current status as a villain. She does not admit to the group that she turned her blades on the one person who tried to help her.
Hidden Regret: The story's internal narrative reveals that Cinder once felt regret for killing him a long time ago, but she keeps this guilt buried deep beneath her persona.
Why She Lies
In the Turboverse Volume 3 lore, Cinder's tragic backstory to create a "closer bond" between the heroes and the villains (who are currently pretending to be heroes). Admitting to murdering a licensed Huntsman who was her only friend would shatter the innocent victim image she uses to gain the sympathy of Weiss and Blake. Instead of the truth, she gives the group meaning and encouraging sentences, leading to a "sweet friendship" between her and Ruby Rose, who she claims looks just like her.
Connection to the "Nothing Bad Ever Happened" Philosophy
Turmoil... serves as the "Proof of Concept" for the motif:
Creative Fixing: By giving Cinder a sympathetic backstory and genuine friendships, I fixed the character from being a target of hate into a complex figure the audience can relate to.
Universal Memories: This arc sets the stage for the Volume 4 Hunt. Because the heroes bonded with Cinder during "Turmoil," their eventual betrayal feels more personal, leading to the symbolic justice where Penny use her memories of the original timeline to defeat her.
Connections to Pyrrha
Turmoil serves as a vital thematic precursor to the inevitable rematch between Pyrrha Nikos and Cinder Fall. While this focuses on Cinder's innocent side, it sets up the emotional stakes for their future conflict through several key connections:
The Subversion of the Original Timeline
In the original RWBY series, Cinder killed Pyrrha without hesitation. In the Turboverse, the "Turmoil" arc introduces a version of Cinder who is fixed to be more sympathetic. This makes a rematch more than just a physical fight; it becomes a clash of ideologies between someone who was consumed by hatred (Cinder) and the Ideal Huntress (Pyrrha).
Personal Betrayal: The rematch carries more weight because Pyrrha and her friends actually shared moments of sympathy with Cinder regarding her abuse under the Madame.
Psychological Warfare: Cinder’s refusal to tell the full truth about killing her mentor Rhodes ensures that when the truth eventually comes out, the betrayal hits Pyrrha and the others significantly harder.
This leads directly into the Volume 4: Hunt. The bond formed here makes the eventual symbolic justice possible. This often involves characters like Penny Polendina using memories of the original timeline to confront and defeat Cinder, contrasting the innocent Cinder seen in the Atlas field trip with the ruthless killer she became.
Shared Trauma
A major connection point is the shared sympathy between the characters. During "Turmoil...", Weiss and Blake bond with Cinder over oppressive family dynamics. This creates a complex dynamic for Pyrrha, who must reconcile the "victim" she met in Atlas with the villain she must fight in a rematch.
The Cinder: Fumigating arc serves as a bridge between Cinder’s tragic origins and her current role as a primary antagonist in the Turboverse. It connects several previous themes and storylines:
1. The Glass Unicorn Origins
The "Fumigating" state is a direct continuation of the Flashback Arcs concerning Cinder’s time in Atlas.
The Shock Collar: In previous entries, it was established that Cinder was forced to wear a shock collar at the Glass Unicorn hotel.
Biological Evolution: Cinder: Fumigating reveals that her fire Semblance isn't just a power, but a "biological defense system" born from the intense physical and psychological trauma of that abuse. Her body literally attracts heat as a way to burn away the memory of her servitude.
2. Parallels to Yang’s "Inner Wolf"
This entry reinforces the ongoing rivalry and thematic mirror between Cinder and Yang Xiao Long.
Thermal Release: While Yang’s fire is linked to her Were-Wolf heritage and protective instincts, Cinder’s fire is purely endothermic and fueled by hatred.
The "Hulk" Comparison: Just as Winter Schnee has a "Hulk-out" state and Yang has her "Inner Wolf," Cinder’s "Fumigating" form is her version of a Human Torch transformation—a physical manifestation of a "boiling point" that has been building since the earliest arcs.
3. Setup for the Pyrrha Rematch
The mechanics of this power explain why Cinder is such a formidable threat in the rematch against Pyrrha Nikos.
Because Cinder has refined her rage into a calculated, surgical heat, she is able to combat Pyrrha’s magnetism with extreme thermal energy, setting the stage for their high-stakes duel in the later volumes.